Skip to content Skip to navigation

LHMP #589 Foxhall 1998 Pandora Unbound


Full citation: 

Foxhall, Lin. 1998. “Pandora Unbound: A Feminist Critique of Foucault's History of Sexuality” in David. H. J. Larmour, Paul A. Miller, and Charles Platter (eds), Rethinking Sexuality: Foucault and Classical Antiquity. Princeton: Princeton University Press. ISBN 9780691016795

Pandora Unbound

* * *

[Note: The majority of this discussion is concerned specifically with Athenian culture, though that isn’t always mentioned explicitly.]

This article continues on the theme of “Foucault has been useful but is flawed with respect to classical history.” A significant part of Foxhall’s critique is that, in focusing narrowly on the internal discussions of the philosophical community, he ignores the reality of the larger social fabric of ancient Greece – the reality of the “others” that philosophers contrasted themselves to. Thus, only the idealized male philosopher is “real” and all else is erased.

Foxhall focuses on that multiplicity of identities that have been erased, including the multiple meanings any given identity can have. (There follows a list of caveats with regard to the material.) It is inevitable that surviving materials center around the “free, adult, male citizen” that the philosophical texts prioritize. Yet female subjectivity can be found implicit in various contexts. Foxhall focuses on three elements: the relationship to time, the construction of households and relationships within them, and the “development and construction of sexuality vis-a-vis social and political relationships.” [Note: Quoted, because I’m not yet certain what this means. Hopefully it will be made clear.]

Gender-specific relationships to time are most obvious in the context of life stages and in how people relate to the past and future outside their own lifetimes. Some historians (including Foucault) represent women as “permanent children,” but this relies on defining adulthood as male adulthood. There were clearly distinguishing stages in a woman’s life, primarily revolving around marriage and child-bearing, with adulthood occurring in the mid-teens. In contrast, men had a more gradual transition to adulthood beginning in the late teens and not fully completed until around 30, the typical age at first marriage. Women’s power within the household tended to increase with age, while men’s social and political importance tended to decline once they were no longer active in the military.

Looking at a greater timespan, women related to the future via their descendants, especially sons, but typically limited by the legally significant three-generation depth. As women were responsible for the household and hence planning for the future of the household, ensuring the success of posterity was in their hands.

Men could only access their posterity via a woman, even though the kinship structure was defined around men. Men were also concerned with a broader time span than the +/-3 generation concerns of the household. This was managed via a discourse of fame and reputation. In this way men, during the brief period of their individual social dominance, strove to achieve a lasting “monumental” dominance via the creation of texts and objects.

Because of age-differential marriage patterns, access to the recent past in a family would tend to come through women. Women were also more prominent in rites of passage.

The three major agricultural festivals of Demeter and Kore were dominated by women and in some cases excluded men entirely (whereas almost no festivals excluded women). The women’s festivals included displays of women’s sexuality, including same-sex behavior, generating male anxiety. Although women’s rituals were essential to the agricultural calendar, the actual work was done primarily by men.

Even within male discourse, the household was the key element of society, not the individual. The household was not simply the private contrast to the public political sphere. Adult men existed in both spheres but the two could overlap. Despite the difference in prestige, household space dominated the geography of the city with public/civic spaces taking up much less space. Within a household, the spaces that could alternate as public or private were marginalized, with most space being private. Political structures were constituted of households, not individuals, and a household could not exist without women. Thus it is misleading to treat women as irrelevant to political life.

Women were also the “glue” that connected the creation of new households, as age differences meant that a woman’s influence spanned two generations while a man’s was confined to one.

Spatially, even the supposedly male-only public space of the agora was permeable to women, as it included the important fountain houses, which were feminine spaces where women could meet and talk while hauling water. As men’s access to the “private” household was largely limited to the one they headed, while women remained connected to both their birth household and married household, there is a sense in which – rather than being imprisoned by gender constraints – women moved more freely than men did. While the official ideal was that the women in a household existed only via their relationship to the male head, in actual practice, women formed bonds within and between households, especially with other women, for their own purposes that could be at odds with men’s authority. (This dynamic is often represented in comic dramas but can also be seen in legal contexts.)

Foxhall does not contest Foucault’s picture of the idealized Greek male control of the sexuality of household members, while himself being free of control. Reality, however, did not always adhere to this ideal. For example, while rape was legally treated as an offense against the man who had authority over the victim, non-legal discourse recognized the injury to the victim as well. Further, the view of women as passive objects in illicit sex is contradicted by the evidence in some law cases indicating long-term illicit relations instigated in some cases by the woman and abetted by female allies. And such a case was not simply an injury done to the “wronged” husband but was a humiliating failure of his authority as well.

In Foucault’s analysis, the tension between “passive” boyhood and the emergence into autonomous adulthood was a central problem, hedged about with ritual and symbolism. But Foxall suggests this ignores the corresponding rupture between the boy and the household. Male sexual identity emerged outside the household in male-only spaces, over a long period of time. (Female sexuality emerged within the household over a much shorter period before marriage marked a transition.) The idealized “older, active erastes” and “younger, passive eromenos” may have been the philosophical archetype but artistic depictions show a much wider range of possibilities, many showing similar-age male pairings, or showing the eromenos clearly aroused (which was contrary to the ideal). Youths who are not yet officially adult are shown having sex with women of various ages. While boys and women may both have been the object of male desire, they were not treated identically or desired for identical reasons.

Another crack in the ideal façade was that, as a man developed sexuality outside the household, it happened outside the authority of the head of household (normally his father) under whose authority and protection he supposedly remained.

Foxhall also notes that, at the point when a son becomes fully adult via marriage, and thus officially out of his father’s influence, his life comes even more under the influence of the women of the household, who take responsibility for training and socializing his new wife.

Time period: 
Place: 

Add new comment